
Ten years ago, someone decided it was worth celebrating “forty years of punk”. But they forgot something.
As Neil Cooper pointed out in this post about Gina Birch and Helen Reddington’s film Stories from the She Punks: “A twenty-minute trailer premiered in 2016 at an event at the British Library as part of an exhibition to mark the fortieth anniversary of punk. The sold-out screening was pretty much the only representation of women in the entire show.”
Viv Albertine did something about it. She graffitied the poster (or “defaced”, as the press coverage put it) with the words “What about the women!!”
It’s part of the UP YOURS! GOD SAVE THE QUEENS festival, organised by Celeste Bell (Poly Styrene’s daughter), Lauren Estelle Jones (Mick Jones’ daughter) and Vivien Goldman (“the punk professor”). And yes, I am aware of the irony of describing women by who their parents were, but it’s relevant here: in particular, Celeste is working hard to keep her mother’s memory alive. (It’s also why there’s some Clash memorabilia in the exhibition: they are the token men.)
The exhibition has been popular, and there’s a lot of good stuff in it. I don’t think I am the target audience, because I don’t do nostalgia and I knew about everything in it already. But I am still glad they are doing it: reclaiming space for our history.
The information board at the exhibition says, accurately: "The punk narrative is still overwhelmingly filtered through a male lens.” And it adds: “This isn't a sub-category of punk: it is the history itself.”
I am starting to feel like a bit of a sub-category, though, because I keep getting asked about “women and punk”. In fact, I’ve just come back from a book festival where I was on a panel about this very thing.
![]() |
| Left to right: me, Helen, Molly |
Even if it feels weird, I will keep talking about this stuff, because it’s testimony. And telling our stories is important. Because we Were There too.
If you want to know what I think about women and punk, most of it is in my book. But here are some FAQs that have come up during this year's book events. And because it’s not just my story, there are references to Helen McCookerybook and Molly Tie, my fellow panellists at Louder than Words.
What was life like as a female music fan before punk?
Before punk, as a smalltown teenager, your boyfriends decided what you were going to see. (It’s not just me: Tessa Pollitt made the same point in a Radio 4 interview.) And the gigs were big and impersonal: I went to see The Who at Charlton in 1976, but all I remember now is the lasers.
During punk, as a student in Liverpool, I was at club gigs. I chose what to go to. And if none of my friends wanted to see the band, I went on my own. That’s significant, because women were not supposed to go to public places on their own in the 1970s.
The gigs were small and intimate, and a lot more exciting. I was always at the front. And I saw on stage people who were my peers. It didn’t matter whether they were male or female. They were my generation, and that’s what mattered.
Who were your role models?
I wasn’t inspired by punk because women were doing things, although in retrospect that was incredibly important. I was inspired by punk because my peer group were doing things.
There’s a great quote in Viv Albertine’s first memoir about seeing the Sex Pistols for the first time: “This is it. At last I see not only that other universe I've always wanted to be part of, but the bridge to it.”
I wasn’t inspired to become a music journalist because of reading Caroline Coon or Julie Burchill or Jane Solanas, although I was glad they were there. I was inspired by the fact that a man of my own age in Liverpool was doing it.
I do write in my book about female punk musicians and how the images they chose were different from the “rock chick” clichés. That’s important, because it challenged the way men thought rock’n’roll should look. (And that’s one of the reasons I love Poly Styrene: because she wore skirts and cardigans.) But it’s not the only thing that was important.
Was punk feminist?
I don’t remember the punk scene in Liverpool being particularly political – it was more of a bohemian spirit – although there must have been some crossover with radical activity in the city. I think the feminism was happening elsewhere.
Helen spoke about a Brighton scene that was part of the squat/activist culture. Maybe that was a southern thing. And Molly, a younger generation, has always assumed punk was political. It didn’t feel like that for me.
There’s a good quote by Caroline Coon in Helen’s book: “When you’re in your own skin, you look outwards, you don’t see yourself ‘as a woman’. You see yourself as a person.” That’s mostly how I felt at the time. And I think that punk gave us permission to see ourselves that way, when perhaps we weren’t allowed to before.
Later, navigating the adult world, feminism gave me a framework for why that world is so shit. Getting hassled by men at gigs I was reviewing was probably one of the things that made me a feminist. But just as bad was being catcalled every time I went to the shops. Two sides of the same coin.
Was music journalism sexist?
Yes, but probably no more or less than anywhere else. Anyway, I’m here to talk about women, not men.
Next question, as Johnny Rotten used to say.
Was punk a safe place for women?
There’s no consensus on this. Helen spoke about a “dark side” to the Brighton punk scene. In fact, she’s written an album about it. Molly has documented in her book the less positive side for women of some subsequent waves of punk.
For me, the 1970s punk scene in Liverpool, centred on a music club and a record shop, felt safe. Maybe it was because many of the main faces on the scene were gay or gender nonconforming. There were lager-drinking lads there too, but they didn’t bother me.
After that scene was over, I remember reviewing a gig by Crass and the Poison Girls. (Yes, let’s have a shout-out for the Poison Girls and their forty-something singer Vi Subversa, who we all thought was so old.) And one bloke came up to me and asked if, as an unaccompanied female, I was frightened with all these punks around.
I looked at him in his leather jacket and studs and I thought to myself: Mate, I’m more punk than you’ll ever be.
I didn’t say it. I still think it. And that’s probably a good place to finish.
![]() |
| From Tessa Pollitt's scrapbook. Punkesses not punkettes! |


No comments:
Post a Comment